Our directory of things of interest

University Directory

The Saharawi people of Western Sahara are still waiting for a homeland. Tensions are now rising among the young

  • Written by  Words: Ferdinando Cotugno Photographs: Francesco Lastrucci
  • Published in Refugees
Gabla, a young Saharawi woman, sits inside the family tent with her daughter. Gabla was born in the Smara refugee camp, has lived in Spain, and is now back in the camps. She dreams of becoming a psychologist and is fluent in Spanish and English Gabla, a young Saharawi woman, sits inside the family tent with her daughter. Gabla was born in the Smara refugee camp, has lived in Spain, and is now back in the camps. She dreams of becoming a psychologist and is fluent in Spanish and English
17 Jun
2020
Since its annexation by Morocco in 1975, Western Sahara has been the subject of a long-running territorial dispute. For the Saharawi people, the wait for a homeland has now spanned more than 40 years. Among the young, tensions are once again rising

You can only get to Western Sahara at night. The flight from Algiers lands at 3am in Tindouf, the largest city within this extreme patch of land in the southwest of Algeria. Nor can you walk freely out of the small airport – it’s a militarized zone and the visa only guarantees one pass. 

Instead, we are escorted by the Algerian army for 50 kilometres to the entrance of the refugee camps. After a seamless change in the dark, we’re taken into the charge of the Polisario, the liberation front that for the past few decades has been supervising this piece of land. This is where the disputed geographical entity we call ‘Western Sahara’ begins. Its borders, as they’re traced in books and magazines, are often the matter of cartographic skirmishes between Polisario and Moroccan diplomacy, who both tend to correct every unwelcome representation. 

2Feature SaharawiFINAL

Western Sahara is actually a European story of two Spanish colonies – Saguia el-Hamra and Río de Oro – which Spain abandoned in 1975 and which Morocco then annexed to its territory, in the face of the indigenous Saharawi people’s ambition for self-determination­. A war ensued, long and painful like all battles fought in the desert, ending in 1991 with an armistice and an unofficial territorial division. Morocco held on to the coastal area, richer in resources (particularly phosphates), leaving the Saharawi a slice of desert, mostly inhabitable, which they now call the Free Zone. 

FLastrucci Saharawi 32Two women walk past sand dunes on the outskirts of the Dakhla camp. They pass the ruins of an old prison where Moroccan war prisoners were held. Dakhla is the most isolated of the five camps in Algerian territory and the last one to get electric power a few years ago

Today, this community is divided into three parts: 170,000 live in refugee camps within Algerian territory, around 200,000 in what is today the southern part of Morocco, even though the Saharawi still refer to it as the Occupied Zone, and around 30,000 in the Free Zone, a buffer between the first two. 

In order to understand the Saharawi desire to become a nation state, one needs to get out of the refugee camps in Algeria, full of an unrest artificially enhanced by decades of humanitarian help, and travel to the Free Zone. Proper roads cut off at the check-point where Algeria ends and the hamada begins – the kind of desert that is made of rocks and stone, harder and harsher than sand and dunes. After the check-point, the only human beings we meet are nomadic herders, cameleers and drivers headed to Mauritania, their trucks full of goods, moving down beaten tracks.

There is neither phone signal nor electricity here. Our driver Mohammed can only follow his compass, his instinct and his experience. The landscape around us is dotted with abandoned tanks, left behind by the Moroccan army. The Free Zone is inhabited by soldiers and the occasional family, who choose to stay here because, as someone who was mutilated in war against Morocco tells me: ‘Even spitting, if it’s on your own soil, has a different flavour.’ Cities are really outposts populated by a few hundred people, with a school, a marketplace and a small clinic.

FLastrucci Saharawi 7In Rabouni, the administrative centre of the five Saharawi refugee camps in Algerian land, containers with donated goods from NGOs wait to be distributed

FLastrucci Saharawi 117In the middle of the hamada desert near Rabouni, camels stand inside a fence made by old cars

One of these outposts is the current capital of Western Sahara, Tifariti. The territory’s government acts out of the refugee camps, but a need for a capital for the future state arose, and a presidential palace has been built in Tifariti, rising over a rock overlooking the desert. Used only to hold official ceremonies, the rest of the time it stands empty and closed off, guarded by two soldiers who pass the time making tea. There’s a satellite dish spreading a Wi-Fi signal; it becomes a gathering ground for the people living nearby, who sit by it to latch onto an internet connection, a limited and rare resource here. 

The western border of the Free Zone is delimited by one of the longest walls in the world, only reachable after once again crossing the desert for many hours. Built in the 1980s and guarded by the Moroccan army, it is an uneven embankment, 1,700 miles long and surrounded by hidden land mines which still regularly claim victims. 

FLastrucci Saharawi 129A member of the Polisario patrols the land near the border in the Free Zone. Thousands of Liberation Army men are present to patrol and secure the land and to assist nomads

FLastrucci Saharawi 130A man stands in a hospital near Bir Lehlu, the Free Zone, built with international donations

The Free Zone is a symbol of the geographical aspirations of the Saharawi. However, their political and social life thrives in the refugee camps, spontaneously born in the mid-1970s when Algeria chose to receive Saharawi families escaping the war. Here, the Saharawi government tends to its office, handles the diplomatic network and keeps order in the streets. There’s a nightly curfew, and strict security measures have been in place since 2011, when a cell of Malian jihadists kidnapped three NGO workers, two Spaniards and an Italian. They were only freed nine months later. 

During the day the camps are bustling with activity – unofficial markets, exchange of gas cylinders, goat and camel farming, distribution of food from UNHCR and Red Crescent, educational projects. By night there’s only darkness and silence. For every Saharawi person, the camps are still a temporary solution, but the idea of ‘temporary’ has by now become feeble, as they reach the third generation of the refugees who outran the war. 

FLastrucci Saharawi layout 1View of Boujdour/27 de Febrero refugee camp, one of the five camps in Algeria. Each camp (wilaya) is divided into six or eight provinces (dairas) 

FLastrucci Saharawi layout 3A young girl plays in the courtyard of her house in the Smara refugee camp. Smara is the biggest of the five camps in Algeria

Each of the camps bears the name of a city in Western Sahara: Aioun, Dakhla, Smara, Tifariti, and each harbours members of the same families and the same traditions as the real locations. In Dakhla they still propose fish to guests because the occupied Dakhla (or just Dakhla in Morocco, depending on your point of view) lies close to an extremely abundant sea. In these camps, those who are now grandparents used to live in tents, but their children built houses made with bricks of sand. Now, houses built in concrete are becoming more frequent, partly as a protection against flooding. Rains here are rare but disastrous. Electricity caught on only in 2015, there are no sewers, no running water or an appropriate system of distribution for domestic gas. 

Get Geographical delivered to your door!
signup buttonAs we brace ourselves on our personal islands, it can be hard to picture the processes of the planet continuing to whir. Marooned in our homes, it’s vital that we stay positive, motivated and informed. Geographical is committed to helping you explore the world from the comfort of your sofa. Get the world delivered to your door, with Geographical.

Subscribe today to Geographical’s monthly print and digital magazine and save 30% off the cover price! 

There’s something else lacking too. Western Sahara has no universities; young people relocating to Tindouf, Algiers or Spain for their studies have to choose between becoming part of the diaspora or going back to the camps, where the only professional possibilities are the army or the government bureaucracy. A larger portion of the Saharawis don’t work at all and many spend their lives inside the home. When they invite us in to serve tea in the Berber fashion, and start telling their stories, the word we hear most is ‘esperar’ – ‘to wait’. Colonisation left the Saharawi an inheritance of Spanish as a second language, while their mother tongue is Hassaniya, a local dialect of Arabic. 

FLastrucci Saharawi 9Ahmed and his three children roast camel kebabs at home in Auserd refugee camp, one of the five main camps in Algerian territory

The end point of these conversations is always the same: ever since the 1991 armistice, Saharawis have been waiting for a referendum and the birth of their nation. It’s not an unreasonable expectation, considering that the Saharawi have repeatedly been promised the right to self-determination by the UN, Spain and Morocco. But more than 40 years have passed without a referendum being held. During this time, the camps have been managed by the UN mission MINURSO (United Nations Mission for the Referendum in Western Sahara) which is officially in charge of creating the political conditions for self-determination but which, in reality, has been managing the status quo, trying to avoid the explosion of the current standoff into violence. 

It is this possibility – of a return to violence – that also underlies every conversation. A wait this long generates rifts within a population, and today that is most evident between the young – who often talk about reclaiming weapons and who share videos of military trainings on Tik Tok – and the women and the elders, the only ones left upholding an old promise of a peaceful struggle. 

FLastrucci Saharawi 22A boy trains at a boxing school in Smara, donated to the camp by an Italian former boxer

FLastrucci Saharawi 78In the Rabouni administrative camp, young people sit in a classroom at a military and general training school for women

‘We don’t want a war because we think we could win it, but because we want to draw the attention of the world,’ explains Nayem Lahrad. He is a coordinator for the Red Crescent volunteering force and has obtained a Spanish passport. 

But as Damaha Mohamed, mayor of Smara, one of the biggest refugee camps says: ‘The young ones say they want a war and that they’re ready to fight it. Those youngsters don’t know what war is, they don’t know what it has taken from us.’

An old Saharawi adage holds that: what an old man laying down sees, a standing young man doesn’t – but young people have to see something. ‘Better to become a graveyard than keep living like this,’ one man tells me. ‘Every day I wake up, I pray, and I wait for war.’ Time mixed with frustration has led to an infection that keeps on festering. 

‘We opted for a peaceful struggle, but it becomes ever so difficult to explain it to the newer generations,’ Omar Mih, a representative of Western Sahara inside European institutions, explains. ‘The idea keeps spreading that the war has brought more results than peace, and we, the pacifist ones, are getting older.’

FLastrucci Saharawi 20Women sort newly arrived humanitarian aid (dates and homeware) in a local administrative office in the daira of Tifariti (a district of Smara camp)

FLastrucci Saharawi 16Women play volleyball right after a community meeting in Smara

The war with Morocco and the ensuing militarisation of the population also brought another side effect, this time more positive. There is no other Arabic community in which women have as much emancipation or hold a more central role than in Western Sahara. With the men fighting and overseeing the Free Zone, women grabbed the reins of society. They became mayors, governors, ministers and doctors.

Today, women manage humanitarian aid and international relations; they welcome visiting delegations. While waiting for political independence, women here have conquered their own personal subjugation. It’s an oft-repeated concept, a marketing strategy for forgotten causes, but it is also the truth. ‘The Saharawi history moves through women,’ Dumaha Ali Mohammed, mayor of Faria, tells me.

FLastrucci Saharawi 182This family decided to come back to the Free Zone after three decades in the refugee camps. Inside her tent, the matriarch sits with her granddaughter named Hurriya (literarily meaning ‘freedom’) in her lap, with her daughters sitting around her

One of the most important of these women is Aminatou Haidar, the so-called ‘Gandhi of Western Sahara’ who in 2019 received the Right Livelihood Award, commonly referred to as the ‘alternative Nobel Prize’. Born in 1967, when Western Sahara was under Spanish colonial rule, she has spent her life as a nonviolent activist and human rights defender, peacefully campaigning for the independence of her homeland. Her picture hangs in every house, every office, every school. But her work is also considered a shared responsibility.

One evening, while dining with a local family, I go outside to look up at the sky. In the dark, a figure approaches me. I can’t make out a face, but I hear the voice and realise it is a young girl. She tells me her name is Mariam; she wants to practice her English. ‘When I grow up I want to be a diplomat,’ she says at the end of our chat. ‘I want to offer a future to myself and the children I will have.’

FLastrucci Saharawi 41On the outskirts of Auserd camp, a door still stands while the sand dunes slowly cover what remains of a mud-built house that collapsed during a recent flood

FLastrucci Saharawi 222Bir Lehlu, in the Free Zone of Western Sahara.  A member of the military stands in front of a wall covered with photos of war martyrs, inside the ‘war museum’ at the Saharawi military barracks

Then there is Nuena Djllbani, who at 59 years old heads a school for girls in the camps, teaching them everything from how to use a Kalashnikov to how to stitch a wound, cook, use a computer, name all the bones inside the human hand and speak English. Every day, she listens and learns their desires. ‘They want what girls all over the world want,’ she says. ‘Independence, a car, they want to eat fish at a restaurant, a house with a garden. But you can’t have personal independence if your community has none.’

Before we say our goodbyes Nuena teaches me the azgarit, the cry the Saharawi women use to herald weddings, births and rebellion. Her tongue folds and runs horizontally on her lips as a high sound comes up, fast and excited. ‘Now imagine the sound of a thousand azgarits all together; that’s what we will do when we finally get back home.’

FLastrucci Saharawi 188Stars over the military base of Bir Lehlu, in the Free Zone. The whole territory has no roads, no electricity, no running water and no phone lines. Access is difficult even for the Saharawi due to the harsh climate of the Sahara and the hamada desert, the military tension and the abundance of land mines

 

Ferdinando Cotugno is a freelance journalist, Francesco Lastrucci is a freelance photographer based in the Mediterranean area, India and Colombia


Stay connected with the Geographical newsletter!
signup buttonSince its inception in 1935, Geographical has reported on many thousands of global issues, allowing readers to look past the boundaries and borders of our world and take a broader perspective. In these turbulent times, we’re still committed to telling expansive stories from across the globe, highlighting the everyday lives of normal but extraordinary people. Stay informed and engaged with Geographical.

Get Geographical’s latest news delivered straight to your inbox every Friday!

Related items

Julysub 2020

geo line break v3

Free eBooks - Geographical Newsletter

geo line break v3

geo line break v3

University of Winchester

geo line break v3

EDUCATION PARTNERS

Aberystwyth University University of Greenwich The University of Derby

TRAVEL PARTNERS

Ponant

Silversea

Travel the Unknown

NEVER MISS A STORY - Follow Geographical on Social

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.